Fear

Robot writing a book

Lately, I’ve been going through AI panic cycles, ranging from “meh, this stuff’s never going to be as good at telling stories as me” to “Augh, augh, I’ll never be able to compete with a flood of tailored AI-generated books!” Back and forth, back and forth, fear and confidence, confidence and fear.

But now, I’ve figured it out. And my money is on “there’s a bit to worry about, but once you reach a certain level of skill, there’s no replacing a human writer.”

Here’s why:

The current generation of AI wonders is based on LLM:s – Large Language Models. For those of you who know nothing about AI, and have lived beneath a rock, LLM:s are the “we’re scraping the entire web and training our gigantic models to approximate human output” kind of AI. But that’s not important for this discussion.

What is important is this: LLM:s are averaging engines. They aren’t capable of thought, or content recognition, or even random output. They take whatever you type into them, and give you the answer that an average person would give.

Here’s an uplifting proof. That’s from a overview of a new AI tool that allows users to interact with several models at once. The question is a very open-ended “tell me a joke.”

Give that prompt to 1 000 people, and you’ll end up with 900 different jokes, and 50 people who say “What? Me? Joke? No, I couldn’t…”

3 of the 5 questioned LLM:s reply with the exact same joke.

Exact. Same. Joke.

Here’s the segment (1 minute to watch):

 

That result in itself is a joke, but here’s what’s going on: they’re using similar training data, and that data likely has a not insignificant amount of copies of that joke. When asked to tell a joke, the LLM:s look to what tokens follow the joke prompt, and return the same joke. And since it’s a science-themed joke, it’s likely (at least in my mind) that it’s a joke used as an example in numerous computer science texts on the web. That the LLM:s have scraped, and are now regurgitating.

There’s a study (to which I’ve forgotten the link) that asked LLM:s to generate random numbers between 1 and 100, over and over again. In a truly random scenario, you should get an output that resembles a wavy line – each number represented roughly the same amount of times. Guess what happened with the LLM:s? Half of those “random” numbers turned out to be “42” and a quarter were “69”…

And when the researcher pressed the LLM to generate the random numbers with memory, 100 times in a row, they got each number exactly once – also NOT a random selection.

That’s because the LLM:s can’t do random. They can only do average.

TLDR: LLM:s tend to produce the SAME output.

Here’s a great video by Professor Sabine Hossenfelder explaining why (5 minutes):

What does that mean for us writers, artists, musicians, and general creatives?

We’re going to see a period of AI being more and more able to create formulaic stories. If you’re the kind of writer that only writes to market, strictly following a formula (not mentioning any names, but I’m looking at you, Best-Selling Brand Name Author #2,) then you’ll likely have a very hard time in the next ten years.

AI can be a competent writer. AI can follow a template. AI can do filler. If you need to churn out your average, empty newsletter or background image or Lorem Ipsum junk text, AI is your buddy.

AI doesn’t innovate. And that’s they key.

Because what will happen is what always happens: readers flock to a new genre, they fall in love with it, they want more of it – and then they fall out of love, and want something new. And LLM:s can’t do new. Not without a lot of human prompting and support, and sometimes not even then.

So for me, who writes quirky, off-genre books that combine diverse elements, diverse casts, and basically stuff that I find cool, I’m not worried. AI will, for the foreseeable future, have a hard time duplicating what I do. And when readers tire of same-old, same-old and search for something that’s beyond what their AI-dominated genres can deliver, maybe they’ll discover something by me.

Pen icon

I had fears. Big fears. Soul-crushing fears.

Let me give you an example. In 2003, I was a semi-finalist in the Writers of the Future contest. I’d sent in my story (which, BTW, predicted Bluetooth headsets 15 years before they became a thing) after months of sleepless nights and fearing what would happen.

I finished in the top 10, but I didn’t win.

Every quarter, WotF receives some 4 000 entries. My story was in the top-10 of those entries. The top 0,25%. It was judged to be better than 99,75% of all stories submitted that quarter.

But I didn’t win. (more…)

Pen icon
Courage and Fear quote - David Farland

Courage and Fear quote - David Farland I’ve started to realize when I’m afraid.

That’s a big step, really. It lets me deal with my creativity problems in a completely new light. See, there’s this moment when I’m thinking that I would like to sit down and write. And I feel this lethargy suffuse me, like I’m being slowly dipped in a pool of warm chocolate. It would be so much nicer to just read a bit. Check my email. And there’s this thingamajig I’ve been looking for all week.

But when I scratch below the surface I feel something else. I feel this suction in my gut, as if I’m about to crest the first ridge on a roller coaster. It’s faint, but it’s there and if I scratch at it I can pull it up for my conscious inspection. And I see fear. (more…)

Pen icon
Would the world end if I missed the bus Quote

Would the world end if I missed the bus QuoteImagine this: you’re going to work. You’re one of those ecological types who takes the train (or you’re too poor to drive, who knows). You’re walking down to the station when you realize that the train is already there – you’ve got seconds before it leaves! So you start running, coat flapping (hey, maybe you’re one of those cool guys who wear a coat), leather patches on your cardigan slapping your elbows (or not). And then the train leaves. Without you. What happens?

Nothing. (more…)

Pen icon

Get Free Science Fiction & Fantasy Stories!

I hope you enjoyed this content!

If so, subscribe to monthly(-ish) newsletter and get free copies of some of my stories and collections!

No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time!

Get Free Science Fiction & Fantasy Stories!

I hope you enjoyed this content!

If so, subscribe to monthly(-ish) newsletter and get free copies of some of my stories and collections!

No spam, and you can unsubscribe at any time!